When the evenings get dark we think about music, and by the time the notices start to appear in the papers about Bach's Christmas Oratorio, Handel's Messiah, and the Brandenburg Concertos, it's likely our cherry-picked "fall season" is already well underway. Not that there's any real planning or subscription involved. In the course of the last week we heard two outstanding concerts, both of them in St. Paul.
On Sunday afternoon Consortium Carissimi performed selections from Monteverdi's La Salve Morale et Spirituale, a heterogeneous collection of pieces he put together and published in 1640. The translation would be "a moral and spiritual forest"—great title!
The show was at three in the afternoon in one of the courtrooms on the third floor of the Landmark Center, and the proceedings had a casual atmosphere that almost made you feel like you were part of the group. One woman was taping the event on a tripod using her phone. A baroque trombone (no valves) was sitting on a table right behind my head. Guests and musicians greeted each other warmly. No one was taking tickets. The nineteen members of the ensemble—singers and instrumentalists—gradually settled into their places, but then started to converse again with a colleague or adjust a music stand. Director Garrick Comeaux and bassist Julie Elhard, standing ten feet apart, couldn't seem to agree on when to start the program. We watched all the comings and goings as if it were the introduction to a neo-realist film by Ermanno Olmi.
The first half of the program consisted of singers and instrumentalists in various combinations performing relatively brief selections. One of the tenors did a solo number. Two violinists put a lot of energy into a somewhat repetitive piece full of call-and-response figures to piercing effect.
I don't remember precisely which was which, but the performances were invariably fresh and engaging, and the long Mass that concluded the program offered a tremendous blast of rich vocal harmonies. Wow! I say "long" but it wasn't too long. Rich, but also somehow light, unlike so many concert Masses that are titanic to the point of bombast and tediousness.
Two days later we returned to St. Paul to hear an afternoon performance of the Bach solo violin sonatas and partitas performed by the Greek virtuoso Leonidas Kavakos. Unlike the material in the previous concert, which was entirely new to me, I've been listening to these pieces since my college years. I even taught myself one of the partitas on the guitar.
But they're naked works, full of mournful scraping sounds and double and triple stops that threaten to upset the flow. No one listens to them very often, I think, great though they are. They're deep yet also lively, sometimes harsh, often mournful and intense. How they would sound on a concert stage I had no idea, but Kavakos pulled it off, both by his playing and his serious, untheatrical demeanor. The thought and feeling were ever present, the care and virtuosity merely a means to an end.
It was a recital not to be forgotten.
Back home, we cooked up a pot of leek and squash risotto while listening to a CD of the three sonatas that weren't included on the afternoon program performed by the Venetian virtuoso Guiliano Carmignola. The tone was slightly different, but Carmignola touched on the same array of emotions.