Jazz is a world unto itself, a world of oral traditions,
insider knowledge, nightclubs, drugs, and the constant struggle to earn a
living playing music that very few people like—but some people adore. The Golden
Age of the art-form stretches from t he Swing
era, when Broadway musicals, movies, dance bands, and ballroom orchestras flooded
the theaters and radio waves, to the small-group scene that followed, during
which the most gifted of the musicians who had cut their teeth in the big bands
formed small combos within which they could "stretch out" and
"strut their stuff" in more intimate environments.
In
3 Shades of Blue
James Kaplan has chosen the ideal form for exploring this world, drawing on established
narratives, interviews, and previously unpublished oral histories to convey the
uncertainties, inspirations, marketing challenges, personality clashes, and
dumb luck, both good and bad, that fueled this remarkable burst of creativity. He
defends his chosen point of focus in the introduction as follows:
Other
categories would follow, but I confess that in the genres of bebop and hard bop,
jazz created, in the quarter century between, roughly, 1942 and 1967, I find
almost all of the jazz I want and need.
That's not a good sentence grammatically, but it conveys the author's personal enthusiasm, and that's what keeps the narrative rolling.
Kaplan relishes the gossip, the stories, and he knows how to
milk the material. For example, he offers an extended quote by trumpeter Wallace
Roney about how Miles got Coltrane to come back to his band. At the time, Miles
had just returned to the States from Paris, and he wanted to form a new band.
Coltrane was just finishing up a gig at the Five Spot with Thelonious Monk, and
Miles wanted Coltrane back. Here is Roney's version:
One night he comes to Trane and
says, 'Trane, come on back in the band, man.' Trane said, 'No, Miles—I like it here. I’m havin’ fun.' Miles
said, 'You don’t want to play this shit—we playing some different shitl' Coltrane said, 'No, Miles, I’m enjoying this.'
Miles said, 'Come on. Come on back
home.' He said, 'Philly’s back. Red’s back. And we got a little boy,
Cannonball.' He said, “Just come on and play some with us.'
In Roney's version, Miles hires Sonny
Rollins on tenor and books a gig at Cafe Bohemia. Then one night Coltrane shows
up, carrying his horn. Cutting a solo short, Miles goes off the bandstand to
talk to him. Sonny takes the next solo, and then, as Miles later tells the story
to Roney, “Wally—Trane got up there and played so much shit, took the
championship belt away from Sonny. Made Sonny go to the bridge!”
It's a fine tale, the kind of
insider scuttlebutt that those who love the music relish, Kaplan among
them. But he prudently adds:
If the account is taken
literally, it has a couple of chronological issues. For one thing, Sonny
Rollins had left Miles’s band in September, while the Monk-Coltrane stand at
the Five Spot was still in full bloom. For another, Rollins’s famous
sabbatical from jazz, during which he practiced every day on the walkway of the
Williamsburg Bridge, didn’t happen until the summer of 1959, and by his own
account, a cutting contest with Coltrane had nothing to do with it. And Red
Garland didn’t rejoin Miles until late December, at which point Rollins was
long gone.
But the spirit of the legend is
intact in Roney’s telling. Coltrane’s playing had developed exponentially
during his time with Monk: “Working with Monk brought me close to a musical
architect of the highest order," lie told Down Beat editor Don DeMicheal in August 1960. “I felt I learned
from him in every way—through the senses, theoretically, technically....
Kaplan not only loves the stories and the music, he also
possesses the technical smarts to explain, in layman's terms, what was novel
about the new paths these musicians were charting. For example, he makes an effort
to explain what the shift from "playing the changes" to modal jazz
was all about by a brief reference to Miles' tune "Milestones."
The tune was the first full
example of the change in musical direction Coltrane referred to in that 1960
interview, Miles’s moving to the use of fewer and fewer chord changes in songs.
“Milestones” is based on just two changes, focusing on modes rather than
chords: the heart-racing opening section, with the three horns puffing its
familiar staccato four-note figure, bop-bop-BOP-bop, is in G Dorian (you can
find it yourself by playing a white-keys-only scale from G to G on a piano);
the tune then shifts to A Aeolian (white keys from A to A), then back to Dorian
before repeating the progression.
No one else in jazz was doing this
then.
I'm not sure how interesting any
of this would be to someone who isn't already familiar with the music, but
Kaplan does the reader a favor by devoting a good deal of his time to a single
LP,
Kind of Blue, widely considered
to be the greatest work of the post-bop era. That album is unquestionably
great, and very easy to like, because all of the tracks are slow, quiet, moody,
and brilliantly executed. But due to that very fact,
it doesn't really exemplify the era, which spanned from hard bop and bossa nova to dreamy West Coast cool. Then again, no
single LP possibly could.
I had the good fortune to take to
jazz at an early age, and I heard the second legendary Miles Davis Quintet--the one that
included Herbie Hancock and Wayne Shorter--twice within the intimate
confines of the old Guthrie Theater. But by this time, the late 60s, Miles and his band were well down the road into edgy modal compositions. Sure, I liked Kind of Blue. But I liked Sorcerer, Nefertiti, and Filles de
Kilimanjaro better.
Which raises the question Kaplan
presents in the subtitle of his book. "The Lost Empire of Cool." One
of his themes is that jazz lost its audience because it got too far
out, too cool, too something. You
could no longer dance to it.
Well, every book needs a one-line
"hook," I guess, as a gift to reviewers and publishers' reps. Kaplan spends
little time defending it. He toys in one chapter with the phrase "Jazz
Died in 1959," but neither he nor
anyone else believes it. No one could listen to pianists Red Garland or Wynton
Kelly today, for example, without being reminded of how much Bill Evans, Herbie
Hancock, and Chick Corea brought to jazz in the 1960s.
Kaplan himself obviously loves the
music of the era he's describing and he wouldn't have it any other way. Maybe Jazz died in 1970, when Miles released Bitches Brew?
Well, no one paints like Giotto these days, either.